A supplier invoice comes in, and finance has to decide: pay it, or hold it for now? The answer sits in three documents that often live in three different places: the purchase order, the goods receipt, and the invoice itself.
Three way matching is how you make sure all three agree before money leaves. In practice, those three documents almost never sit side by side.
What is three way matching?
Before an invoice is paid, three purchasing documents are checked against each other. First, the PO: the official order from the buyer, listing the items, quantities, and agreed prices. Second, the goods receipt: the warehouse's record of what actually arrived and how much. Third, the supplier invoice: the bill, with the quantities and prices being charged.
The invoice is only approved when all three agree, or when the difference falls within the tolerance the company has set.
What gets matched
| Match | What's checked | Example problem |
|---|---|---|
| PO and goods receipt | Items and quantity | Fewer goods arrived than ordered |
| PO and invoice | Unit price and total | The invoice price is higher than the PO price |
| Goods receipt and invoice | Quantity received and quantity billed | The supplier bills the whole order when only part was shipped |
The flow, from PO to payment
- Purchasing creates the PO and sends it to the supplier.
- The supplier ships the goods. The warehouse checks them and records the quantity received on the goods receipt.
- The supplier sends the invoice.
- Finance matches the invoice against the PO and the goods receipt: items, quantity, price, and total.
- If everything matches, the invoice goes into the payment schedule. If the difference is above tolerance, it's held until it's sorted out.
Three scenarios with numbers
Say a company orders 100 units of raw material at Rp50,000 per unit. All figures below exclude tax.
| Scenario | PO | Received | Invoice | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Match | 100 units × Rp50,000 = Rp5,000,000 | 100 units | 100 units × Rp50,000 = Rp5,000,000 | Approved and paid Rp5,000,000 |
| Quantity mismatch | 100 units × Rp50,000 = Rp5,000,000 | 95 units | 100 units × Rp50,000 = Rp5,000,000 | Held. Difference of 5 units or Rp250,000. Pay Rp4,750,000 for 95 units once the supplier issues a correction note, or wait for the rest of the goods to arrive |
| Price mismatch | 100 units × Rp50,000 = Rp5,000,000 | 100 units | 100 units × Rp52,000 = Rp5,200,000 | Held. Difference of Rp2,000 per unit or Rp200,000 (4%). Ask the supplier for a credit note, or have purchasing approve the new price and update the PO |
When there's a mismatch
Almost no company requires the numbers to match exactly in every case. There's usually a tolerance, for example a price difference of up to 1 or 2 percent, or a quantity difference within a set limit, depending on each company's policy. Below tolerance can be approved straight away. Above it goes into a review queue.
- Quantity mismatch: ask the warehouse whether the goods are short, damaged, or haven't arrived. The supplier then ships the rest or issues a correction note.
- Price mismatch: ask purchasing whether a new price was agreed. If not, request a credit note or a corrected invoice.
- Duplicate invoice: the same invoice number or amount comes in twice, and one of them gets rejected.
- Goods received, invoice not yet: at closing, the value is still recognized as an accrued liability so that month's report is complete.
If it isn't matched
Without matching, a company can pay for goods that haven't arrived, pay a price different from what was agreed, or pay the same invoice twice. Mismatches like these usually surface only at reconciliation or audit, long after the money is gone.
The effects spill into reporting. Accounts payable and inventory numbers become inaccurate, and the finance team has to trace documents again during monthly closing. Correct purchase quantities and prices are also the basis for calculating cost of goods manufactured.
Two way, three way, four way
Two way matching only compares the PO with the invoice. It's simpler, but it doesn't check whether the goods actually arrived. Three way matching adds the goods receipt, so payment only goes out for goods that were received. Some companies add one more step, a quality inspection report (often called four way matching), especially for goods where quality is critical.
Manual or in a system
Done manually, finance matches three documents one by one, usually from three sources: the PO file from purchasing, the receiving record from the warehouse, and the invoice from email. That works for small volumes. Once transactions grow, mismatches only surface at month-end and the time goes into hunting for documents.
In an integrated system, all three documents live in one place, so matching can run automatically and people only check what's flagged. In Jasper Enterprise (JET), the Purchase-to-Pay feature matches POs, goods received, and invoices automatically, and the system flags anything that doesn't line up first.
Frequently asked
Does every purchase need three way matching?
Not necessarily. Many companies use it for purchases of stocked goods or high-value items, and a simpler check for services or small expenses. The cut-off depends on risk and company policy.
What if only part of the goods arrive?
The goods receipt records the quantity actually received. The invoice is matched against that quantity, and the rest of the order stays open on the PO until the goods arrive or the order is closed.
Who owns each step?
Usually purchasing creates the PO, the warehouse records receipt, and finance matches and approves payment. Keeping those three roles separate is also an internal control in itself.
What's the difference between two way and three way matching?
Two way only compares the PO and the invoice. Three way adds the goods receipt, so payment only goes out for goods that were really received.
Dealing with a pile of invoices that don't match their POs? Tell our team about it and we'll look at it together. Chat on WhatsApp.
Want to see POs, goods received, and invoices matched automatically in a system? See it in a Jasper Enterprise demo.
The numbers in the examples are illustrative. Tolerances and payment policies differ from company to company, so adapt this to your internal procedures and check with your finance team or auditor.
← Artikel